Wood vs. Steel Garage Doors: Which Is Best?

There are numerous factors to consider when purchasing a new garage door, including a variety of styles, colors, designs, and types of garage doors. The material for garage doors is the most important factor in determining how long your garage door will last. Different garage door materials can withstand varying amounts of use and necessitate varying levels of regular maintenance, so it’s critical to consider your typical garage door usage.

Wooden garage doors and steel garage doors are two of the most popular materials. With our wood vs steel comparison, Cary’s garage door repair experts explain to you which types of material might be better for you especially to withstand harsh weather conditions!

Pros and Cons of Wood Garage Doors

Wooden doors have a number of advantages, as well as drawbacks.


Aesthetic Appearance: Wooden doors offer a rustic elegance for a timelessly beautiful and skillfully made appearance. A wood garage door can improve your home’s curb appeal and all-around aesthetic appeal.

Long-lasting: Wooden garage doors are naturally very strong, and they are frequently constructed with a hardboard panel and a strong hemlock frame for overall strength. Due to the varying patterns and natural grain of the wood, minor scuffs and scratches do not stand out as much as they do on other durable materials.


Maintenance: Wood garage doors, unlike steel garage doors, will need to be refinished or painted every few years. Because wood doors are more susceptible to sun damage, they are not recommended for dry, sunny, and hot climates.

Insulation: Wood doors, on average, provide less insulation than steel doors.

Price: Since solid wood cannot be produced as quickly or easily as steel, it is more expensive.

Difference between real wood and faux wood doors

Although real wood and fake wood appear similar, they have very different properties.

A real wood garage door is typically made of solid cedar or redwood, whereas a faux wood garage door is made of steel with a wood overlay. This means that a faux wood door is much lighter than a real wood door due to the wood overlay and is typically less expensive.

A high-quality faux wood door with the same look and feel as a real wood door can be indistinguishable. The primary distinctions are in price, maintenance requirements, and availability.

However, real wood has several advantages over faux wood, including greater durability and resale value. While a high-quality faux wood door will be difficult to tell apart from real wood, the authentic appearance can vary depending on quality, and some options may not be as convincing up close.

Consider price, durability, proper maintenance requirements, and long-term value when deciding between faux and real wood.

Pros and Cons of steel garage doors

There are several advantages and disadvantages of steel garage doors to consider before making your decision:


Insulation: Steel doors are well-insulated and can be insulated in a variety of ways. Premium steel doors insulated with polyurethane or polystyrene regulate temperature and make the doors easier and quieter to operate.

Maintenance: Steel doors are typically easier to maintain than wood doors because they are lighter and will not warp or crack due to extreme weather conditions. Corrosion-resistant coatings are usually available as well.

Price: Steel garage doors cost less than wood doors.


Damage: Steel doors dent and damage more easily than wood doors. Small dents are easy to remove, but larger dents can be difficult to repair. Steel doors with a thicker gauge can provide more resistance.

Wood and Steel Garage Doors in Cary & Raleigh, NC

Tip Top Garage Doors Raleigh offers a large selection of wood, faux wood, and steel doors.

Our Classic Wood Collection includes handcrafted redwood, hemlock, and cedar solid wood options. They offer traditional raised, flush, and recessed panel designs, allowing you to choose what works best for your home. The natural wood’s beauty will add instant curb appeal to your home.

The carriage house style combines character and historical charm with convenient automatic operation. It is strong, strikingly beautiful, and energy-efficient. The collection includes eight carriage house designs that can be painted, stained, or mixed and matched, as well as top section/window panel designs that can be painted, stained, or mixed and matched.

Our Reserve Wood Collection Semi-Custom Series offers additional carriage house design options for a historical appearance and modern operation. This collection features six designs in three wood species and a variety of finish options. To match the architecture of your home, the top section/window panel designs can be mixed and matched, stained, or painted.

Our Modern Steel Collection features steel options that are both beautiful and easy to maintain. These doors, which are available in a variety of styles, are an ideal complement to mid-century modern and contemporary home styles. Doors are available in a variety of finishes, including faux wood, with or without grooves.

Tip Top Garage Doors Raleigh can assist you in locating the ideal garage door for your home. When you need garage door sales, installation, or repairs, we are Cary’s garage door repair experts to call.

Garage Door repair technicians in Cary will respond quickly if you notice any problems with your garage door. Tip Top Garage Doors Raleigh has a wide variety of tools, parts, and expertise to repair any common garage door product like quality garage door openers, garage door cables, and all.

Call Garage Door Experts at Tip Top Garage Doors Cary at (919)-701-3003 to schedule a service call.